by Part-Timer » Apr 21st, '08, 15:15
I think the only dealer I've not had any problems with is Top Secret Magic. As far as I can recall, everything has been in stock when I've been told it was, everything has gone out when I was told it would, and I can't remember ever being sent the wrong item, or something being left out.
I don't expect everyone to be perfect; the real test is how the problem is sorted out.
I have found Magicbox to be very fast to sort out mistakes (although thinking about it, I might have had proportionately more things go wrong with them than other dealers).
I know some people have had difficulties with Alakazam, but they've always been quite helpful to me, and things get sorted out.
I think a lot of people have had trouble with items going missing in the post, but where I live, the service is fairly reliable (apart from a suspicious lack of post on certain days). Couriers, however, have caused me quite a lot of grief. Turning up at odd hours, possibly not ringing the bell (had that with the postman, too), depots miles away, so you can't collect the package yourself, no indication of if the re-delivery will be morning or afternoon, and even ignoring the re-delivery date specified, then bringing it the next day! And yes, a whole day was wasted waiting in for it.
EDIT: On the subject of Outlaw, I've had some horrific waiting times too, but I don't treat them as regular dealers. To me, they're prop creators, and sometimes it is a very slow process for them to meet the orders. It's still a shame to be kept waiting for a long time, especially when others seem to be getting their items weeks earlier, but Rick is helpful, and he replies to e-mails, unlike some dealers.