Ponderings-ebook

Review area devoted to Magic Downloads, DVDs, Videos and similar non printed formats.

Moderators: bananafish, support, Rob, Lady of Mystery, nickj, Mandrake

Best prices around! A web site set up to sell my book, THE STRIPPER DECK, and future magical/mentalism titles. Manufacturer of modern & unique magic apparatus! World-Of-Magic, Suppliers of quality Magic Worldwide Sorcery Shop - Home of the ITR ink cartridges

Ponderings-ebook

Postby Waters » Wed Jul 23, 2008 3:41 am



"Cardza" was kind enough to post his review (below) in the Mentalist Only section for consideration. I place this here now, as I am offering a 25% off of ebooks on my website which includes the reviewed ebook below. This price will be available until Sunday evening this weekend.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This has got a fair bit of attention of a few others forums, but I've not seen any mention of it here - thought it best to rectify that because this is an absolutely fantastic E-Book!

Firstly, the presentation is excellent. It's all very clear and easy on the eyes. Sean has a writing style which manages to pack in all the information, all the subtleties and thinking behind the effects which make them so strong, quite concisely. There were one or two typos but nothing major whatsoever.

It's $30/£15 (or so) and is available from WatersMindWorks.com.

With that said, let's look at the

Effects

Red-Handed
is quite simply the best Psychological card force I have encountered. It combines the suggestive elements of, for instance, Derren Brown's handlings, with the speed and efficiency of the equivoque (which is not employed here). The suggestion is very sneaky and in my experience a lot more sure-fire than other psychological methods out there.

I combine the underlying handling with a Sean Fields' idea as outlined in X-Rated...

It's quick to learn, but you'll want to spend some time working with it, and getting adjusted to the necessaries, before trying it out. Completely impromptu and a real gem.

Washington DeCeived
A memory demonstration followed by a very nice piece of remote-viewing in which you reveal something about their 'bill', which you have never touched or, if you so wish, seen. Again it is entirely impromptu and a very nicely-structured effect.

Unfortunately it is to us Brits as "Perfect Coin Reading" was to our American friends - not too much use (and, much as I enjoy PCR, Washington DeCeived is much stronger IMO). You'll certainly appreciate the ingenious method however, and it's one worth learning for those times you do find yourself State-Side.

HTP
This is a lovely effect culminating in a drawing duplication. It's a blend of classic methodology (the last phase requires a special something) with the real value being in the presentation - it brings what is often lacking in drawing duplications: motivation. Genuine motivation with an emotional hook.

As this is Sean we're talking about real Psychological tools are involved, and Sean goes into great detail in assisting you in this respect.

The PC Principle
A neat, concise explanation of a Psychological means of controlling your Participant's decision - a handy tool in any mentalist's arsenal indeed. It is, I would say, somewhat lacking in possible applications. Not a problem for the more experienced Performer, and it encourages you to think about how you can use it in your own work, but for the relative newcomer may be left wanting a little bit more direction.

Apparently this will be featured in Banachek's PS3 as well.

(K?NT)
Genius. I'm a big fan of the Kenton/Mahood collaboration "K.E.N.T." (which is required to properly understand this handling of it) so to have a completely pure (read: cardless - propless), impromptu approach is great. Furthermore an excellent rationale for the revelation of the card is given... the last word in "K.E.N.T." - it just doesn't get better than this.

Double Malt
To quote Sean:

Quote:
1. This is a magic-y routine.
2. It uses a standard, store-bought gimmick


- which I imagine most people will already possess (perhaps not the die-hard mentalists, but then I guess this isn't really an effect for them either) and, if you do own it, you'll likely find yourself smiling as I did - at last a decent presentation for it! It is a variant on other presentations, but so much more.

Why Try?
An essay, and not much to say as such. It's definitely thought-provoking, and one any mentalist (whether using actual Psychological techniques or pseudo ones) should read, addressing the benefits of employing these techniques!

Avalon
This is the stand-out item for me. It's Sean's take on Kenton's "Kollossal Killer" and is just fantastic. It's not quite as direct but a lot more compact with a beautiful presentation and a very clever twist on the KK methodology.

This effect embodies everything that is so great about this manuscript: Sean's use of Psychology (in this instance, more covertly, to strengthen your audiences' reaction), his dedication to providing excellent patter, and smart thinking with regards to structure and handling.

You will love this.

Overall
It is so refreshing to see genuine Psychological material released from somebody who knows what they're talking about. Whether you're interested in Psychological material (the real deal), or just want strong effects, you'll find something here I'm sure.

I feel that there could have been perhaps a slight variation in the card material - although they produce relatively different effects, and use differing methodology, they are variants around the same theme: a card revelation - but overall I would say there is a nice blend here.

At the very least you'll perhaps be opened up to a whole new set of techniques, and you'll definitely find a lot to think about (can't help thinking I've missed a trick there...)

9/10 - Highly Recommended.
_________________

To avail yourself of the special price on "Ponderings" or "Ode to Ekman" simply paypal the rate of $22.50 US (Ponderings) or $33.75 US to sean(at)watersmagic.com. Please use the "@" symbol when paying. I have placed the text there to eliminate auto-generated spam messages. I email the file as soon as I see the receipt email from paypal. If you have any questions, you can email me at the same address.

Regards,

Sean

Last edited by Waters on Tue Aug 12, 2008 9:11 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Waters
Junior Member
 
Posts: 20
Joined: Thu Dec 13, 2007 7:44 pm

Postby IAIN » Wed Jul 23, 2008 6:59 pm

you really should buy these ebooks if you like mentalism folks...

sean's a good guy too..

IAIN
 

Postby Mage Tyler » Wed Jul 23, 2008 7:44 pm

Just a quick suggestion that you might want do a quick edit adding the title "Ponderings" at the beginning of the post, since Cardza originally had this information in the topic title.

Might be useful for ease of reading and archive purposes.

User avatar
Mage Tyler
Senior Member
 
Posts: 412
Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2006 5:31 am
Location: USA

Postby Waters » Fri Jul 25, 2008 8:32 pm

Thanks Tyler, I have done as you suggested. I appreciate the comment.


Regards,

Sean

Waters
Junior Member
 
Posts: 20
Joined: Thu Dec 13, 2007 7:44 pm

ponderings e book.

Postby AQUINAS » Wed Jul 30, 2008 6:29 am

i bought this e book the other day and i must say that i like it alot, i just sat reading it and thinking to myself, o yea. such a nice little book to get the mind working with different thinking styles. thanks again for the great service. i would say to anyone to buy it, even if you know all the tricks it is so nice to get other ideas and thoughts on this. just remember that everyone who preforms a trick preforms it differently because its the magician that preforms and not the trick.

AQUINAS
Junior Member
 
Posts: 10
Joined: Sat Jan 20, 2007 8:06 am

Postby Waters » Fri Aug 01, 2008 3:56 am

Thanks for the comment. I hope some of these presentations take these ideas to new places. I have a love for real feeling effects and I hope that some of my methods and presentations have made these feel more real for you and your audiences.

With regards,

Sean

Waters
Junior Member
 
Posts: 20
Joined: Thu Dec 13, 2007 7:44 pm

Postby Sexton Blake » Tue Sep 23, 2008 12:33 pm

Tardiness. I am ashamed.

I started writing a review of Ponderings *ages* ago. But I kept having to go away and do other things, so it was only just now that I got round to finishing it. When I checked for reviews before posting, I saw that in the mean time the one in this thread had been put up.

I've rubbed my chin, and decided to post mine, below, anyway. It may be in review form, but it's still really just my comments on Ponderings, in the Ponderings thread, which is what threads are for, right? Plus, it's not entirely redundant, as I'm not simply saying exactly the same as Cardza. So, though I'm not exactly taking a fiercely opposing position ("Ponderings is terrible! Kill Waters."), it's not an absolutely identical one either.

Anyway. This.

---------------------------------


Ponderings

The site blurb she say:

“This 50 page PDF ebook contains six effects and two essays. Ponderings includes: new methods of suggestion with cards, a routine based upon interpretive psychology, an effect with a dollar bill and even an easy, but effective, "con?" demonstration. I am confident that you will thoroughly enjoy the effects, but the astute reader will discover the real value between the lines. Most can be performed close-up or stand-up, one routine is primarily a "theatrical piece" (but could be applied to close-up). These routines demonstrate a philosophy of performing mental effects. There is also a thought-provoking essay on the use of "pure" techniques and why we should attempt them.

Red-Handed - The most direct suggestive card force in print

Washington DeCeived - A memory effect takes a left turn at Uri's place

HTP - A design duplication with a difference

K?nt - Completely mental presentation for the K.E.N.T. method

The PC Principle - An effective use of embedded commands and an essay

Double Malt - Don't knock it - till you try it

Why Try? - An essay regarding one benefit of using "pure" methodology

Avalon - A coincidence imagined (complete with conversational hypnosis)”

OK, so here are my thoughts.

Sean Waters’s Ponderings is, in his own – accurate - words ‘A collection of mental ideas’. Though there are example scripts for routines with many of these, it’s not a book of ‘mentalist packet tricks’ but more mostly a selection of (psychological - that is, non-physical) utilities and enhancements. If you’d be so trusting as to step onto this small trolley, I will wheel you around them.

Red Handed.
A method of psychologically forcing a thought of card (that is, a card from an imaginary pack, rather than a psycho force of a physical card). It’s actually part force, part, um, statistical likelihood increased further by a verbal subtlety. If you have The Devil’s Picture Book then you’ll be familiar with a good part of the method for a large proportion of this. I mention that to lay down here – and here only; please assume it for the remainder of the review – that Waters draws on/tinkers with/combines/co-opts the methods of many of the greats. He does not hide this fact – on the contrary, he spotlights the originators of this idea or that method – and he does so, it seems, with the knowledge and permission of those people. So, in Ponderings you’ll find not only the products of Waters’s mind but also those of the minds of, for example, Kenton Knepper, Richard Osterlind and Lewis Jones. Which is really rather spiffing. (Actually, I’m not absolutely sure if the major method in Red Handed is something Waters devised independently of Brown; in this one case it’s slightly unclear, but he certainly cites Brown and TDPB elsewhere in the e-Book.)

Anyway, Red Handed is a method you’d be happy to have filed away in your brain to be used at your discretion. You can’t force any card, and you won’t always hit (though Waters gives an out to increase your chances, plus a helpful suggestion for how to deal with ‘misses’). By simple extension, and sensible thought, it could be used to force one of two choices not remotely related to cards too – which increases its value no end.


Washington DeCeived
A part memory, part (sort of) remote vision, or (certainly) mind-reading effect using a bank note. This might be rather good, or it might be a little obvious (though it would never be ‘blatantly obvious’). My guess is that it depends on the audience, and your performance. However, I can’t test it out as, sadly, it relies on a quirk of US currency. It’s perhaps telling, however, that it makes me wish that UK currency had this quirk.

HTP
A way of framing ‘readings’, and a picture duplication effect. (HTP, by the way, is this: http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1O87-Ho ... nique.html) This is a nice means of roping in a (ropey, IMHO, but genuinely-used nonetheless) real psychological technique to give logic to an effect. Waters provides a brief description of the method he would use for the ‘trick’ part of it, but it’s mostly about the performance – about using the context you’ve set. He nicely provides a short list of actual HTP interpretations too, which is a sweet little palette of psycho-babble to paint with.

PC Principle
Ooooo – this is delicious. Again a psycho force method. It’s to push a spec to choose one of two options (not from a selection – just this... or that), that can be used for many, many kinds of things. He shows how the principle can be used to steer someone towards three example choices, but anyone with a synapse will be able to use it to force a wide range of things; just typing this sentence, in fact, I thought of how it could be used to elbow the spec to pick a photo of one person over a photo of another. This is one of those things where one problem of using it will be stopping yourself grinning and shouting, ‘Ha!’ after you’ve controlled the spec with it.

K?ENT
It’s KENT - http://www.talkmagic.co.uk/ftopic22816-0-0-asc-.php – but without cards. YOU WILL NEED TO OWN KENT TO DO THIS: HE DOESN’T REVEAL THAT TRICK’S METHOD. I ‘like’ KENT, but I have two problems with it: one is the fudge about the suit, the other – far more serious – is that it’s not guaranteed. In the KENT booklet it blithely suggests a little over 90% success rate. Well, first off (you’ll know what I mean if you own KENT) I up the cards from five to seven for a start, to improve my odds. Even so, you’ll still fail with alarming frequency – if, say, once in every twenty times I do a trick it’ll fail, that’s 5% too often, thanks; *especially* a trick you have to invest with so much acting and theatre. Throughout the KENT manuscript it’s mentioned that Knepper has Killer as a backup. If you have that, fine. If not, I like its thinking, and I keep it in store in case my back’s against the wall and it gives me a good chance instead of nothing but running away and hiding in the toilets, but, generally: no.

K?NT has the spec imagine the cards instead of using a real pack. This makes it a slightly different effect – useable in different circumstances and with, if you fancy, a very different feel. Very pleasingly, though, Waters logically and smoothly sweeps the suit issue out of the picture from the off, and it’s also (I’m going to declare without collecting any data) far, far more reliable. Why? Because people – especially nudged (and Waters furnishes the simple nudge) – are much more predictable than cards. The method for K?ENT isn’t startling. Don’t expect your brain to firework with astonishment: if you own KENT, and you were told that you had to come up with a cardless KENT to win a year’s supply of cheese, then you’d come up with something very like this. Waters, however, lays it in your lap, and laces it with useful suggestions and hints culled from his experience of doing it.

KENT is something I don’t do voluntarily. K?NT is something I will.

Double Malt.
A magic effect framed in a scam-themed script. You need a couple of (common, ish) gimmicks for this. It’s basically a (two) transpo effect. Waters uses the scam theme to give it more theatrical substance, which it surely does. It’s the most standardly ‘magic’ effect in the e-Book, though. Possibly (Waters intimates this), it’s one of those things that, as a magician, one reads and goes, ‘Meh,’ but that actually plays big to lay people.

Why Try?
Not an effect, but a short op piece on why one should, in Waters’s view, do effects that aren’t one hundred per cent sure of success when there are plenty that are.

Avalon.
This is really nice. This is *really* nice. You know when reviewers caw, “This effect alone is worth the price of the book/DVD!” Well, this one, demonstrably, is worth at least half the price of it: because that’s how much it costs (at least) to buy the manuscript of the principle on which it’s based. But, more than that, it’s a rather delightful thing (that could easily be a delightfully spooky thing too, I must add) that’s qualitatively different from its, erm... mother ship. It’s basically a prediction – or coincidence – effect set around a spec imagining his or herself choosing to stay in a particular room on a particular floor of a hotel. It uses imaginary cards to illustrate the choice. I grimaced a little at the method for getting the colour, I have to say, but once you’ve whisked pass that the subtlety for the suit is sweet, and the actual number/card will baffle/stun/scare the spec into the ground. It’s streamlined its parent method too, which makes things even better, and the script means everything is supremely logical.

(I’ll add that, personally, I’d limit the rooms to twelve rather than thirteen per floor. I’d do this for one hundred per cent safety, and can’t see it being a problem as you’re merely using cards ‘to represent’ a hotel; not in any way doing a card trick where the pack is ‘like a hotel’. Also you could easily, casually dismiss the ace as being the ground floor – or the ‘first floor’, as Americans call it – and hotels don’t have rooms on the ground floor; it’s just the lobby, reception, restaurant, etc.)

So, what does that add up to overall for Ponderings. I feel it adds up to 8/10. Why the two marks docked? Well, it’s because I can’t shake the feeling that $35 – about £15 in proper money - is steep for an e-Book. You might say, “You wrong-headed Nazi, Sexton. It’s the *content* that matters, not the delivery method. *And* - you wearying buffoon – ten quid is pretty much the minimum cost of even a single trick most places. Any less that £15 and he might as well pay for the taxi out of his own pocket so he can come to your house and scream the words into your parsimonious face.” Well, I take your point, I really do (esp. as we all know places on the Net charging you far more than that for one trick - and often a seventy-year-old, known to anyone who’s bothered to read a book or two, trick as well). But you still can’t deny that a physical book is a more pleasing entity. The problem is something like Lewis Jones’s Seventh Heaven. It’s twice as much, yes, but it’s 108 effects over 377 pages all contained – this is the thing – in a lovely, lovely hardback book. I can’t look at it sitting across the room and *not* dock two points for a 50-page e-Book, really.

Overall then, a good collection of thises and thats from what seems to be a thoroughly agreeable gentlemen; it’s just the price that... here it comes! here it comes! ...gives me... steady now! ...gives me cause to ponder.

Last edited by Sexton Blake on Fri Nov 14, 2008 11:16 am, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Sexton Blake
Senior Member
 
Posts: 340
Joined: Tue Mar 21, 2006 2:23 pm
Location: Britain

Postby Mandrake » Tue Sep 23, 2008 2:57 pm

Thanks Sex, despite the awful pun, a Review added to an existing Review is exactly the way to do it!

And bear in mind that YOKAI is a-coming....

--0--
User avatar
Mandrake
.
 
Posts: 25477
Joined: Sun Apr 20, 2003 8:00 pm
Location: UK (66:AH)

Postby Waters » Fri Nov 14, 2008 1:09 am

Sexton,

Thank you for the well-stated and fair review. I truly appreciate you taking the time to do so. I completely agree with your comments and the caveats listed. I think that is one of the best reviews of Ponderings, I have read. I too prefer a hardcopy book, but I just wasn't at a place yet to be willing to invest the time for a full hardbound volume. I am releasing one more ebook, Contemplations (which is the third), in January, and then I will address a hardbound release later. I am a "holder" as well, so I am looking forward to the tactile joy of the real deal. Thanks so much.

With regards,

Sean

Waters
Junior Member
 
Posts: 20
Joined: Thu Dec 13, 2007 7:44 pm


Return to Reviews - Electronic media format

Best prices around! Aeternum Servare Secreta Visit Magicbox for all the latest and best effects! MagicWorld Magic Shop for Magic Tricks Dude That's Cool Magic

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests