Moderators: nickj, Lady of Mystery, Mandrake, bananafish, support
me_simon wrote:I stand corrected. But the blood is still on his hands!!
In looking up Fear Her, I was reminded of The Impossible Planet and The Satan Pit from the same series - two absolutely terrifying episodes. Loved them.
magicrob wrote:Farting Alien on Space Surfboard=Blon Slitheen on Extrapolator (though Part-Timer forgot to add, 'Who Turned Into an Egg'!) from 'Boom Town'
kry10 wrote:But, the river song who DID kill the doctor was a young girl with blonde hair, not the river song we know, so, that must have been an earlier regeneration, not a later one, but, if the bounty hunters said that she will kill the doctor in the future, then, erm, dang, my head is hurting.....
Anyone able to shed some light on things ?????????
Part-Timer wrote:As to the records showing that River Song killed the Doctor - the classic rule of computing might apply - garbage in, garbage out.
themagicwand wrote:I guess I just miss the Daleks. And the Cybermen. And David Tennant.
magicrob wrote:IMDB is most definitely NOT to be trusted; any idiot with a net connection can add information to it.
Jean Eugene Roberts wrote:River Song already killed the Doctor and then brought him back. As for who's in the spacesuit, right now my moneys on the future/paradox Amy Pond.
What confuses me is if River and the Doctors lives are going in opposite directions doesn't that mean 'Lets kill Hitler' was River's first meeting and the Doctors last? Are we not going to see River Song again?
Randy wrote:Last Season ended with not only the plot of who shot The Doctor and how he died (which is actually a throw back to a old Colin Baker episode where his companions see him talking to a mysterious figure in the distance and it turns out it's a future version of the Doctor preparing himself for his death.)
Yes we know now they supposedly "brought her up", even though I find that a huge cop out and load of c*** (not the best). Their daughter is still MIA and really even though the Doctor mentioned it ONCE "Oh I looked for 3 months and found nothing. Welp, let's go have a spot of tea!" I'm still kind of miffed with how nonchalant they are about their kid still missing. Specially sense we were left with a such a huge cliff hanger and then it was promptly pushed under the rug, also due to the fact that this season is pretty much done till next year, because Moffat blew his budget and sucks at actually doing middles.
*end spoilers*
I did like this episode and felt it was decent on it's own and really The Doctor has kind of ignored the time travels of the past before. Wasn't there an old episode where the Time Lords summoned 3 versions of the Doctor in the same time line, and also the Christmas Special had old man scrooge hug his younger self and that didn't screw up the time line or anything. Not to mention the Big Bang/Pandrica Opens.
Part-Timer wrote:I might have remembered this wrong, but didn't the Justice Department's records show the Doctor's death as occurring at Lake Silencio in 2011? Also, the Doctor didn't die from the Judas Tree poison. We've already seen (at Lake Silencio) that if the Doctor actually dies, regenerations don't work, so River saved the Doctor with her remaining regenerations before he actually died.
Jean Eugene Roberts wrote:Part-Timer wrote:I might have remembered this wrong, but didn't the Justice Department's records show the Doctor's death as occurring at Lake Silencio in 2011? Also, the Doctor didn't die from the Judas Tree poison. We've already seen (at Lake Silencio) that if the Doctor actually dies, regenerations don't work, so River saved the Doctor with her remaining regenerations before he actually died.
He did die from the tree poison thats why he couldn't regenerate and river had to give up all her regenerations to bring him back to life. It was a Timelord defib. He was officially dead when she kissed him. So River did murder the Doctor even if she brought him back, perhaps the Justice Department has a 'no take backs' policy.
Jean Eugene Roberts wrote:Part-Timer wrote:I might have remembered this wrong, but didn't the Justice Department's records show the Doctor's death as occurring at Lake Silencio in 2011? Also, the Doctor didn't die from the Judas Tree poison. We've already seen (at Lake Silencio) that if the Doctor actually dies, regenerations don't work, so River saved the Doctor with her remaining regenerations before he actually died.
He did die from the tree poison thats why he couldn't regenerate and river had to give up all her regenerations to bring him back to life. It was a Timelord defib. He was officially dead when she kissed him. So River did murder the Doctor even if she brought him back, perhaps the Justice Department has a 'no take backs' policy.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests