I can't do 10 card tricks, I can probably barely do 10 tricks competently enough to perform them. All of them get the best reactions, that is why I do them.
I have always thought this was a wrong question. If you want good reactions it is nothing to do with the card trick itself. That is only a tool. Any reasonably good card trick will do. YOU are the reason a card trick will go well or not go well. You can show the greatest card trick ever invented and still bore people senseless if you don't go about it in the right way. You should never present card tricks. You should present YOURSELF presenting card tricks! If you do that then even TonyB might like your work.