Moderators: nickj, Lady of Mystery, Mandrake, bananafish, support
OK, first off all I just have to say, I think the magic world has gone to s***. People's ideas or creative property used to be respected. Today people are lying and stealing all over the place and nobody seems to care.
This version of CIB was created in 1999 by Adam Williamson in Wichita, KS USA. and was titled "Pop Top Drop". A description of it first appeared in an issue of the "Linking Ring" that same year. Shortly after this Williamson submitted this original effect plus others to the "David Blaine Road Trip Contest" featured in "Magic Magazine". Blaine was very intrigued by the effect and inquired about featuring this effect in an upcomming television special. (guess it wasn't good enough for Blaine. It never made the cut). Shortly after that it was published as a feature effect in Magic Magazine V09 N6 February 2000. (Why pay $30 for the trick when you can order a back issue for $6) Williamson then marketed the effect through Stevens Magic Emporium where it finally fizzled out and has laid dormant until now.
The other difference here is, in the original when the spectator opened the bottle they could tell it had never really been opened by the sudden release of pressure and the very distinct sound a soda bottle makes when it is first opened.
With Williamson's permission the instructons to this effect will become available online for free within the next few months. I will post a link when it becomes available. With your help maybe we can put cheaters like these out of business. If you know of any other blatant rip offs let us know and we'll expose them too.
But there was a reason this effect didn't take off it the first place.
#1. It's very quirky to set up
#2. It's not practical at all
Save money. Buy the back issue of Magic Magazine V09 N6 February 2000
for only $6 compared to the $30 the other guy will charge you.
I just think people need to give credit where credit is due and stop stealing people's intellectual property and making money off of it. It is ethically wrong, not to mention illegal. Williamson may just have a lawsuit here. Hmmmm.......
Go buy a bottle of soda and a bottle of water. Open them one after the other and hear and feel the difference. Again this is SCIENCE.
The main point here is giving credit where credit is due. I'm sure Williamson wouldn't want any of your money. But he does deserve your respect.
We know for sure we can prove this. The biggest proof would be that the effect appeared in printed form about 6 years prior to your release, and is still available today through Magic Magazine. Don't believe me? Check it out for yourself. Same goes for the issue of "Linking Ring" (Do you even know what that is I wonder) Also the original print documents are available along with the computer files that can prove a creation date and a video with a date and time stamp.
You say nobody's ever heard of it? Well my guess is that most of these people here are just noobs who think that even the ellusionist stuff is original. That guy is a cheat too. If you have been in this business as long as I have you would know that. Ellusionist is a prime example of somebody stealing effects out of books and selling the secret as their own. Ask any reputible magician or dealer with no affiliations and they'll tell you the same. It's one thing for somebody to take an old effect and put a new spin on it and call it something new, but at least have the decency to make a reference to the old.
Again, do your homework before you make claims. I know it's alot of work, but if you're serious about this thing, it shouln't be that big a deal.
here's the desription of the effect:
Performer displays several clear bottles of soda and asks the spectator to choose one. Free choice, no force. The label is removed. A coin is borrowed. The coin then visually and audibly penetrates the bottle and can be seen to sinking to the bottom of the bottle. The bottle is then handed out immediately for examination and opened by the spectator who can feel the pressure being released as well as can hear the sound. The spectator keeps this as a souvenier.
Also, what may not be quirky to you may be so to others. Especially more experienced performers who like purity, and want to concentrate on performance as opposed to hoping they set it up right and praying that it will work...
About releasing it for free... Williamson is a close friend of mine (he is no longer performing, but still lurks in the shadows of the magic community) he has told me he has no desire to release any old effects or new creations for that matter. He has also said he would rather give a secret away for free to make it harder on those trying to turn a profit at his expense. He never released this effect in the hope of being famous or making big money. Thats why he virtually gave it away to the magic community by having it published in a world wide publication. He wanted to give something back to art that he loves so much.
By the way, why should "I be very careful" about anything I say? I live in a free country and can say anything I damn well please. You want to make a legal issue out if it? I dare you to bring it on. My lawyers could use a five minute break. Please. I have my proof. Where is yours?
Also, bottled water is not pressurized. It is not carbonated. Therefore there is no presssure release.
Go buy a bottle of soda and a bottle of water. Open them one after the other and hear and feel the difference. Again this is SCIENCE.
The main point here is giving credit where credit is due. I'm sure Williamson wouldn't want any of your money. But he does deserve your respect.
We know for sure we can prove this. The biggest proof would be that the effect appeared in printed form about 6 years prior to your release, and is still available today through Magic Magazine. Don't believe me? Check it out for yourself. Same goes for the issue of "Linking Ring" (Do you even know what that is I wonder) Also the original print documents are available along with the computer files that can prove a creation date and a video with a date and time stamp.
You say nobody's ever heard of it? Well my guess is that most of these people here are just noobs who think that even the ellusionist stuff is original. That guy is a cheat too. If you have been in this business as long as I have you would know that. Ellusionist is a prime example of somebody stealing effects out of books and selling the secret as their own. Ask any reputible magician or dealer with no affiliations and they'll tell you the same. It's one thing for somebody to take an old effect and put a new spin on it and call it something new, but at least have the decency to make a reference to the old.
Again, do your homework before you make claims. I know it's alot of work, but if you're serious about this thing, it shouln't be that big a deal.
here's the desription of the effect:
Performer displays several clear bottles of soda and asks the spectator to choose one. Free choice, no force. The label is removed. A coin is borrowed. The coin then visually and audibly penetrates the bottle and can be seen to sinking to the bottom of the bottle. The bottle is then handed out immediately for examination and opened by the spectator who can feel the pressure being released as well as can hear the sound. The spectator keeps this as a souvenier.
Also, what may not be quirky to you may be so to others. Especially more experienced performers who like purity, and want to concentrate on performance as opposed to hoping they set it up right and praying that it will work...
About releasing it for free... Williamson is a close friend of mine (he is no longer performing, but still lurks in the shadows of the magic community) he has told me he has no desire to release any old effects or new creations for that matter. He has also said he would rather give a secret away for free to make it harder on those trying to turn a profit at his expense. He never released this effect in the hope of being famous or making big money. Thats why he virtually gave it away to the magic community by having it published in a world wide publication. He wanted to give something back to art that he loves so much.
By the way, why should "I be very careful" about anything I say? I live in a free country and can say anything I damn well please. You want to make a legal issue out if it? I dare you to bring it on. My lawyers could use a five minute break. Please. I have my proof. Where is yours?
bronz wrote:Why's everyone so irate? The poor lad has an idea and goes to the effort of putting together a product only to be shot down by a bunch of pedants. People have ideas, sometimes different people have the same idea about something similar at the same time, just because one of them happens to have better industry connections than the other is neither here nor there.
The CIB plot is pretty common in magic and and seems to be very popular amongst magicians, it's almost inevitable that at some point there will be some similar effects released. Frankly I reckon the good ol' folding coin 'original' is still up there with the best or failing that the striking vanish variation is pretty good. Not to demean anyone's creativity here, that's just the way I happen to feel.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests