by cymru1991 » Jul 29th, '07, 23:07
I'm not really sure how you distinguish "non-classy" and "classy" magic. For example, if you take a Dai Vernon performance of the cups and balls (which I would count as classy). If you change the metal cups to paper cups, use balls ofscrewed up paper instead of sponge and ditch the green baize cloth. Also, take away Dai Vernon and replace him with me in working clothes (torn jeans etc). Finally, take away any patter, and replace it with spontaneous ramblings. There is absolutely NO class whatsoever in this. However, I would be performing the very same trick.
What this says to me is that, surely, class comes from the appearance of the magician, as well as the props he is using. If instead, I were to use the exact props as Dai Vernon, wear a smart suit and use carefully scripted patter to create a brilliant effect and wow the audience. Would this be counted as classy? To some extent, I believe so. (Never as classy as Dai Vernon because this is me we are talking about, and I have a long, long way to go to gain ANY sort of credibility as a magician).
Another point to consider isthat the majority of "class" (if that makes sense), is not in the mechanics of the effect, but in the presentation. If you were to take a simple card trick, like poker player's picnic, and use flourishes and carefully scripted patter and jokes (as well as a good appearance), would this be classy? To some extent, I think so.
To conclude then, I believe that "class" can be "created" from many elements, such as appearance and presentation as well as the effect used. Obviously, the chances are that an effect that is created in 5 minutes, and then performed will have little or no class as it is poorly thought out and not "road tested" and improved, no matter how expensive the suit being worn is or how funny the jokes are. I am using this extreme to highlight that of course the effect being used can play a part in wether it is "classy" or not, but at the end of the day, it is down to the performer to look presentable, know his moves/sleights inside out/upside down and to have an effective, rehearsed line of patter. This, coupled with "road testing" and a wealth of experince, I think, is the true definition of "class" in magic.
James, 19, Lifelong student of magic and will carry on learning for the rest of my days if I'm a very lucky boy.