Moderators: nickj, Lady of Mystery, Mandrake, bananafish, support
Atomo wrote:i am also a proud owner of WOW, and for those of you who seem to think that this effect is on a par with the erdnase colour change, i have to tell you that you are kidding yourselves. The erdnase change, while being a pretty move, looks like exactly what it is, a clever peice of sleight of hand. The effect of WOW is completely different- it looks dangerously close to being REAL MAGIC.
no.1 WOW - unexplainable, the audience dont seem to care about the plastic wallet, as only 1 card is cleanly pulled out of it, their suspicions are focused on the card, which of course is completely examinable!
no.4 Turdnase- "if i just wave my hand over the cards in this sort of weird unatural way, (slide up, slide down, slide up again)we see the card has changed! -the audience looks at you like 'hmmm nice slieght'.
Funny how performers have been using it for many years to great effect then isn't it?
Actually you can do an Erdnase, throw in some suggestions afterwards to change their recollection of what exactly happened.
The only difference is is instead of thinking "sleight of hand" they think "what's that wallet all about?".
Atomo wrote:Funny how performers have been using it for many years to great effect then isn't it?
Actually you can do an Erdnase, throw in some suggestions afterwards to change their recollection of what exactly happened.
The only difference is is instead of thinking "sleight of hand" they think "what's that wallet all about?".
Which raises an interesting point to do with the psychology of what we as magicians are trying to acheive. are we happy to accept that the audience is aware of sleight of hand, and sit back and take credit for being a skilled card handler. OR do we want to create a magical mystery which cannot be attributed to sleight of hand.
And this is where opinions become divided, i imagine that performers who are of the first school of thought (pro sleight of hand) are also the type of performers who enjoy flourishes and aim to be seem as highly skilled with cards. I personally feel that any effects which can move away from the easy conclusion of " he did some sleight of hand" are more powerful, as the mystery they are left with will itch at their brains for much longer.
I dont want to get into a anti-erdnase rant, but i would like to put forward an experience of mine as Exhibit A against Erdnase:
Recently me and some mates sat down to watch Dynamo's Underground Magic DVD, in which he frequently performs the Erdnase change. One of my friends, who has no knowledge or even a particular interest in magic, grabbed his poker cards and after a while said " hey look i can do that thing he was doing" I.e The Erdnase colour change. It was a pretty clumsy performance but he had sussed the method.
I perform WOW as a transposition effect, where their card changes places with the card in the wallet. This way you can turn the wallet into a plus rather than a negative point by saying " now we'll put this card in here to make sure i cant touch it". No one goes near the wallet, it is transparent, they can see right through it, what is there to suspect?in over 10 performances, so far no one has even asked to look at it....what does that mean? well if my psychoanalysis is correct it means that they attribute the workings of the method to something else entirely. I think it helps to leave the wallet lying on the table as if your not bothered about it, this bluff adds to the illusions that the wallet is beyond suspicion, you dont care about it so why should they? its just clear plastic right?
peace Atomo
yoshi wrote:or the 'heat' in my hands.
Return to Reviews - Tricks 'n Props
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests