by Demitri » Sep 18th, '06, 18:49
Wipe-off signature - This move needs some more ironing out. Your break flashes quite a bit before the actual work begins, and the motions don't really gel with me. Your "wipes" at the beginning are fine - and it sets up the move very well, but there is a noticeable difference between the set up and execution moves. Your wipe is much slower and more deliberate, which makes it look suspicious. My suggestion would be to either work on the handling to make the change faster - or slow down your preliminary wiping motions to match the speed of the change. Keep the pacing consistent throughout. Either way you go about it, the change will be that much stronger when the motions are the same.
The ECC was a little slow, but still an effective change. Nicely done.
Your turnover revelation was nicely done. Not something you see in your average ACR, so this was a welcome addition.
Your tilt needs a bit of tuning up. First, the "other" break should NEVER flash. This bit of flash here, I think, kills the depth illusion. This is a personal preference, but I also didn't like you pushing the card in, only to completely remove it before sliding it in again. Why would you say that's about the middle, then pull it out? The illusion is created at that exact moment, the pause and removal only detracts from it, it doesn't heighten it. Keep the card where it was and continue the move without hesitation.
The pop up move was done perfectly. I've always loved this phase of the routine. I also like how this, in some ways, actually makes your job easier for the next phase. Brilliant thinking here.
The paperclipped ending was pulled off flawlessly, but in this particular video it has no meaning or weight. You should have brought a bit of focus onto the paperclip BEFORE the effect began. OR, give it some more depth when you first introduce it. It's introduction into the routine seemed offhand and pointless - so the revelation isn't nearly as strong in the end. The performance of the effect was flawless, I just think it needs more presentational work.
Outstanding job, as always.