by Michael Jay » May 19th, '07, 06:37
There is a great deal of real gold in those obscure books and 99.99% of all magic being marketed today can be traced back into those books.
So, quite literally, if you're looking to make a mark in magic that is creatively your own, you'll do better going to the obscure and old books to get the information and update it yourself, rather than letting everyone else update it and taking it from them.
Ellusionist and Penguin make huge profits from mining those old and obscure books and repackaging it for sale to the younger magicians. One of the latest offerings was that effect where you blow a big puff of smoke out after lighting a match ("Warning"). That came from a Jean Hugard publication from 1938.
Further, a card effect that I presented after working it through and putting on my own twist to it was seen by another magician that actually told me the name of the book that I pulled it from (for the record: the original name of the trick was "Cagliostro's Spectacles" from "Magic as a Hobby" by Bruce Elliott in 1948).
Personally, I find it refreshing that any up and coming magicians give enough of a damn about where we came from to have this kind of request for birthday gifts. Most of them, in my experience, are asking which trick deck they should get or if the raven is better than the M5.
And, as far as I'm concerned, even if his thinking is off (which, I don't think that it is), at least he'll be learning our history rather than blowing his money (or, in this case, birthday presents) on the new garbage.
Mike.
This post has been edited (Demitri got the wrong end of the stick in his original post, so some of my post is a direct statement to what he'd said and may not make sense in the context above...)