The Magic Herring wrote:I have a bit of advice that I heard from Gregory Wilson,
don't do the retention coin vanish, those weren't his exact words,
but you get the general idea. I have nothing against the retention vanish,
I think it's really good, but it's not however natural to put a coin in your hand in that manner.
There are 2 things you can do:
Make your fake put look the same as your real put
or
Make your real put look the same as your fake put
(if that makes any sense at all)
At the end of the day it's your choice which sleights to do
It may not be natural but it works. It is not natural to pick up a coin with one hand only to put it into another. Heck its not natural to vanish a coin in the first place. Done correctly the audience is so into the effect by the time the vanish is revealed the spectator doesn't remember how you put the coin into the hand. The French Drop is so far from natural yet...
Most of magic is not natural. But I do understand the point. I usually use the Goshman toss or whatever it is where you toss the coin from one hand to the other. But that is just because I like it not because one is more natural then the other. Although thinking about it, it is more natural to just non chalantly 'toss' the coin from one hand to the other.
It is also not natural to fan the cards, or ribbon spread them on the table or let them cascade from hand to hand. Or for that matter even pick a card why not just think of a card? It is up to the performer to create the naturalness of a situation.
Hope that makes sense. I'm moody and tired today.