by Pasta » Mar 23rd, '09, 20:08
Some of this is similar to what has been said, but...
I have three different card-to-pocket scenarios. I only do your type of CtP in one of the three.
(1) I'm going in with the card to pull it out immediately. This isn't your problem case, and this usually doesn't cause any trouble.
(2) I want to exhibit an empty hand and then pull the card out, but it has to work right now. For this, I will load an indifferent card at any point during, well, the entire day I suppose. I go in with a clearly empty hand, show that "their" card is there, put it back, and then go back in right away (but loaded this time) to show them the face. (Suitable patter makes this work just fine.)
(3) (The best case.) I want to exhibit an empty hand and then reach in for the card, but I don't want to have to do the indifferent card dance of #2. This is your situation. My solution: don't require it to work. In other words, do this when you know the misdirections are in place, and do a different reveal when they aren't. I'll switch into a clean CtP reveal when (like in the pub example above) the situation is there for the taking. Basically, I let the situation guide the effect rather than forcing the effect into a situation that I may not have complete control over.
Gratuitous metaphor: If you see there are alligators in the lake, it's fine to cancel your swimming plans and go for a hike instead. They're both nice ways to spend the day, and no one will ever know that you had planned to go swimming except you.
In the other case (switching into a CtP), just yesterday I had p---ed a card and had the spec look through the deck. I wasn't intending to pocket it, but they were sooooo into looking for that card in the deck that I could have gone out for coffee and come back and they would still be focused on that deck. So I slipped the card into the pocket and quickly put my hands up near the deck to help them search.