lindz wrote:place the card on top then give it a really good false cut and shuffle
I wonder how consistently just an 'on the top, then a
simple false cut' would work? And I mean a simple false cut, nothing remotely flourishy or (apparently) confusing to the eyes - a Slydini, say. You'd have to point out that the card was being lost (presumably with an, 'OK, we'll just bury that is the pack somewhere [and move straight on]' rather than something awful like, 'I will now cut your card into the pack'), but there's a wonderful 'open' cleanness to it, isn't there? The card is replaced, the spec can see where she's replaced it, the magician cuts it into the pack very 'plainly', and the deck is on the table - the magic isn't even touching it anymore.
But anyway, the reason I have a card returned into a dribble is that I have the spec select the card from a dribble. I think you need to do that or it looks suspicious. If I ask the spec to choose from a fan, I have them replace it in fan. In the above scenario, for example, I think it'd be best to tell the spec to cut the deck and take the top card before having it returned and lost by cutting the top card in.