I'd agree with variety, try magic from all the different genres.
Reading posts on this forum will give you much useful information on where to go from here from quite a variety of different perspectives. There are a number of threads going into some detail on this issue.
Reading the reviews section will give you some idea on which tricks people here have liked or disliked and some idea how difficult they are.
There are a number of debates on the pro's and con's on gimmicked tricks vs sleight of hand and learning from which type of source.
You will get views from experienced people or from beginners that may have only recently faced the issues that you are now facing.
Then if you take the time to build relationships with some of the people on the board you will also find a lot of help off board via PM/email or AIM if you have it.
All of that is before you spend a penny on books, DVd's or tricks.
So wishing you all the best on your magical journey
