by Demitri » Mar 8th, '07, 08:17
Again, nice effect.
My only problem with this effect, and others in this genre - is that more and more of these variations are either moving away from, or completely forgetting about what is the most magical part of the effect.
The object that is now in the bottle - shouldn't be able to GO IN THE BOTTLE.
How good is the effect, if the spectator can drop the object into the bottle, himself. Coin in bottle/Cap in bottle effects play stronger, because the spectator CAN'T get the object in there, no matter what they do.
This effect, and your method is very nice for creating the illusion - but regardless of how flawless your presentation is - if the object that is inside the bottle easily fits inside the bottle - then they always have an "out" to detract from the strength of the effect.
I have similar reservations with the Prohibition effect. A bent bottle cap can easily go into a bottle - so I feel the "magic" is diminished here.
I will say one thing - your method is very clever. You may have some trouble with the initial misdirection (which is easily fixed the more you perform the effect) but your timing of the penetration is very good.