You are being given excellent advice in this thread. Everything that I see above is pure gold. Unfortunately, the magic industry is riddled with an overwhelming amount of garbage and the problem becomes seperating the wheat from the chaff.
(You can probably tell already that my post isn't going to be anywhere near as useful as those above and, no doubt, those to come.)
What your job is, is to find the stuff that will work for you. As stated previously in the thread, everyone is suggesting ACR but tiw thinks that ACR isn't such a good idea. His opinion is valid. I fully agree that ACR is passe - it seems that you just can't be a magician unless you have a rip-rousing ACR routine. Personally, I don't have one.
But, this is
opinion. So, should you have an ACR or not? Well, I don't know. You are the only one who can decide this. This particular fact is the point that I'm trying to make in this post and why this post will simply not be as valuable/helpful to you as the others who are giving you specific things that you can immediately purchase or find to start using in your walk around act.
I strongly suggest that you look for things that can be done in your hands or in your spectator's hands. When doing walk around, you will come upon two situations: Restaurant Style and Cocktail Style.
With restaurant style, if you have effects that need a table then you'll find that you have to move stuff (like glasses, salt shakers, plates, etc.) to give yourself a performance area. You might also need a close up mat to avoid coins clanging against the table or cards that are difficult to pick up off of a flat, hard surface. This means carrying the damn thing around with you as well as moving stuff to find a place for it. Oftentimes, people don't like having their space invaded and simply gives you another problem to overcome at the table. The easiest way to avoid this situation is to do effects that are in the hands.
With cocktail style, you are standing and your audience is standing. If you need a table, then you either have to bring one with you (which makes you, in effect, stationary) or you have to use a table that's handy, meaning that you have to move stuff and generally get in people's way. Again, the easiest way to overcome these things are to choose effects that are all in the hands.
Suggested above is CMHC, which is entirely in the hands and, if performed properly, stunning. The problem here is that there are magicians who will tell you that this is also passe (although I'm not one of them). So, again, this comes down to opinion.
In fact, whether or not the effects being given to you above are good or bad is, again, a matter of opinion. So, how to figure out what you should and shouldn't do...
I really want my routine to have something to be remembered by in it.
Each and every trick in existance has one, specific thing about it that makes it memorable - that's
YOU.
Let's take ACR as an example. I may just do an ACR for a table and then you do an ACR immediately following mine at the same table. Mine will be forgetable, by yours will be memorable.
Why?
Because my rendition lacks pizzaz whereas yours has lots of pizzaz. And therein lies what makes any given trick on the face of this earth memorable.
YOU.
You see, it doesn't matter what tricks you do. What matters is how you do those tricks, how much of yourself goes into those tricks and what makes those tricks artistically your own. That's what people will remember.
Going back to CMHC:
A while back I was at a party over at a friend's house. This guy likes to announce to everyone that I am a magician. I love the guy, but I don't need the pressure...Anyway, I was asked to show a trick. I declined, they pushed. Okay, I asked my buddy if he had any rubber bands and he went and found a couple. A fat one and a skinny one (not a good coupling of bands for the effect, but workable).
I performed the effect and a guy looked at me and said, "Wow! I saw another magician do this and you're much better than him."
What did I do any differently? Nothing, from a technical point of view. Everything, from a performance point of view.
You, and you alone, are what makes any given trick memorable. Nothing else.
So, you can go over these lists that the good folks of this site are giving you and you can find the effects that fit you. In the end game, though, it is you and you alone that will make or break these effects.
And, I think, that's the most important thing that you can (and
must) learn.
Mike.