Lady of Mystery wrote:but why is it so important? 90% of what the pass can do, can be done by much simpler methods. It's certainly not something that I think should be learnt early. Get the basics down and then maybe you might want to learn it latter on.
I do agree here with you Lommie that it isn't something that should be learnt early on, as the frustration involved can be almost enough to make someone quit card magic. On the other hand, it is true that what the pass does (ie. brings a selected card from the middle to the top or vice versa) can be done in easier ways. However, are there any other alternatives that are as
effective as the pass? After the all when done correctly, the pass brings the card to the top when merely squaring the deck up. The deck can then be put down, safe in the knowledge that the card has been controlled to the top. Easier methods such as the side slip or just an injog, outjog or side jog are perfectly usable, but the deck needs to be held for that bit longer, and you generally need to do something extra, like shuffle off or cut or something. As far as the side slip is concerned, I personally use it sparingly as I find it takes to long and you need some sort of cover ie. turning to speak to an audience member as "the dirt is done" so to speak. These alternatives I find just don't have the same impact as when you use the pass. After all I think that "Card goes into centre, square up, card on top" is more effective than "card into middle, deck held in hands, shuffle off/cut/double cut, now card is back on top. On the other hand, if you're just using it for a control, then the above (ie. the amount of time the deck is in your hands or wether you shuffle/cut or whatever) is probably irrelevant.
I suppose that I am a bit of a "pass snob" so to speak (you're not alone Queen of clubs!:wink:), and if I couldn't do the pass then I wouldn't take this point of view... each to their own really...
Incidentally, I think Darwin Ortiz discusses the pros and cons of the effectiveness of moves such as the pass in strong magic which is worth a read
James, 19, Lifelong student of magic and will carry on learning for the rest of my days if I'm a very lucky boy.