While I would certainly never argue with The Curator on this front (he is one of the Gods of Bizarre, after all) I would have to question his suggestion of the Cafe given the rather pronounced bias that site has towards mentalists and bizarrists via the very obvious Christian right-hand controlling the rudders there and of course, the plethora of egos that run the roost, seeing it a high honor of some sort.
Track down the Shadow Network, the Immortals and groups along those lines and learn from those that actually do Bizarre & Haunted Magick rather than a group of magicians that think a bit of stage blood on a card is all you need to be a Bizarrist.
Eugene could be seen as Bizarre-Light given his penchant for the esoteric and related fantasiful themes for presentation. But more than anything he's a magician and that's by his own definition.
Fairie has a point in what she has said about Mentalism in conjunction to Bizarre work but in truth, Bizarre has kind of become its own entity to which Mentalism is only one small part; most such performers lean towards the whole storyteller (ghost and macabre tales), frequently using items common to occult studies (tarot for an example) but not always. Roni Shachnaey, Gene Poinc, Ed Solomon are great examples in that much of what they each offer comes from tall tales woven around artifacts, unique antique boxes, etc.
Another point that should probably be made here, is that not all Bizarrists do Seances or Ghostly material just as not all are Macabrist that deal with themes such as mass murder, torture, and such.
I bring this up simply as food for thought; you don't have to embrace your inner Jack-the-Ripper or Alister Crowley to do Bizarre work; Jules Vern can work just as well, as can the worlds of Barnum and Robert Ripley, so let such things serve as your guide when taking this particular journey in that being a pack-rat of the strange and morose can be just as much fun (if not more) as one that conjures the darkest minions of Hell.

Have Fun!