by TomSwirly » Feb 2nd, '10, 20:16
Has anyone actually seen this Ultracinese in person? The video is extremely interesting...
Regarding "is it a good trick" - I agree that the first poster questioning this was rather harsh, and also that the pileon afterward was rather harsh - but sometimes you need to be harsh to get things done!
There are two completely different categories of magic trick.
Most tricks are entertaining stunts. While they might examine my fingerchopper or my deck of cards and find nothing, they know that I'm somehow manipulating these items to fool them.
The power structure between magician and audience in these cases is a little dodgy - you're risking being a "smart alec". "Ha, ha, you can't figure this out!"
I actually have a bit I sometimes do before I do a couple of tricks. I explain the problem above to the audience, apologize, and then say that magic tricks are more like tiny plays than anything else. "If you spent all your time worrying at it, you'd no doubt figure out how everything was done, but the fun is in the little story and in actually being fooled."
(Sometimes I talk about "your friend who explains to you in movies that the haircuts are all wrong for King Arthur's time" - this usually get a laugh.)
I do a lot of tricks like this - Color Monte (classic three-card packet trick) is one I've been doing for mumble-mumble years (I just got it again on sale for about $5/a couple of quid and it's still entertaining!)
Recently I have a small number tricks that look like "real magic".
There's a copper/silver transposition I do (can't remember the name! reply and I'll dig it up if interested) where you place a coin in your spectator's hand, balance the copper coin on the back of that hand, wipe your fingers over it for a second... and then it's silver and you can show your hands empty and have them examine everything. (I'm slightly cheating with that desc. but that's how the audience perceives it).
The original DVD had a "move" in it. I worked on that stupid trick until there wasn't one move at all - that every single gesture is completely logical.
I can almost fool myself. It's a great trick.
Now, when I did this properly for the first time, I experienced something I hadn't before - the audience as a whole gasped.
Someone later commented when I did this another time, "It was like the world got a little slippery for a moment."
So there are a small number of tricks that appear to simply break the laws of nature. They're best demonstrated with as little presentation as possible, as slowly as you can possibly manage. You don't have to explain anything, you just do it, no apologies.
There's that copper/silver I have. I have a short routine with a regular coin that's amazing. I've been doing Extreme Burn recently - 4 bills of one type change to another right in front of you - and I get that same result of impossibleness.
Strangely, I just resurrected what I thought was a dumb trick I got in Australia many years ago - a spiral disk with a handle that you spin, producing a cool optical illusion where you see a grey disk appearing on the surface of the disk rotating backward. You do this a few times, and then the spin solidifies into a coin that you give the audience. (Can you say, "Paddle move"?)
I think it's the optical illusion part - everyone loves those and they think the trick is over when you've demonstrated it. But again, somehow, this actually marvels people.
What I'm getting to is that this trick, if it's as good as the demo, could be such a marvel. No threads?! (The demo makes it clear that magnets are out. Magnets are generally out for motion-related things, because that inverse square law means that magnetic force goes from too little to too much in a very short distance... there are only a few tricks that use magnets for motion and those rely on some other physical property as well...)
Has anyone actually seen this? Hints on the reliability of the mechanism? What are the weak points? How do I actuate it? How are the angles?!
(The video gives the impression of perfect angles but...)
Thanks in advance!
I worked