Grimshaw wrote:'Perfection' is a strong word isn't it. How about 'To the best of your ability' as some diluted but more applicable words.
Maybe Derango can do the sleights 'perfect'ly well in the comfort of their practice zone, but when faced with spectators perfection becomes unobtainable, as increased heart rate and sweaty hands renders sleights more difficult than they were initially.
I think the advice to stop performing a trick until it's perfected would probably render many budding magicians as bedroom performers only, as I'm sure many will agree that tricks really only come into their own when performed regularly. You need to perform them to perfect them. I'm sure some of the more snobby amongst us may consider the idea of some magicians confined to their rooms a brilliant one. In doing so however, you create a thousand more Youtube uploaders.
Perhaps - and this is going out on a limb here - perhaps Derango loses control of the card through some other process they've added into the trick. In other words, they are making it their own rather than following the method exactly as laid out in a book. This is a good thing and should be encouraged surely. Though it may be causing them problems now, at least independent thought is being entertained.
Got to say i feel some responses to this thread are rather pious. We're here to help aren't we? Telling someone to stay indoors until they're absolutely perfect isn't the best advice you can give to someone.
Thanks, that's what I do. The way I perform the trick I use an insane amount of shuffling, that's just my presentation, so I sometimes miss the card by 1 or 2. And as you say, I'm somebody who tends to struggle more in real life performing - no matter what level of perfection I reach in practicing, mistakes tend to happen about 1 in 20 times in performances, that's why I carry a brainwave.
If I'm doing the Biddle Trick 5 times a day, 1 in 20 means 1 mistake every 4 days, which means my brainwave deck runs out of steam in a few weeks, so I have to use FP on it again