talkmagic.co.uk

Smoke or zamiels rose which is better post your opinion

I personally prefer Smoke. i hate smoking and this is the only thing that's good about it in my opinion (TM smokers i am sorry) the effect is shear poetry specially when Derren does it. Although i think zamiels rose is very clever and poetry also i just prefer smoke as its such a good effect.

I really don't feel that any one, single effect always necessarily has to be 'better' (or 'worse') than any other.

These "XYZ Vs. ABC - Which Is Better?" topics are frequently a little pointless - as anyone will sooner or later mention, it's ALWAYS a matter of personal opinion, handling, presentation, skill etc., which will make or break a performance of any effect.

far do's

I keep expecting Harry Hill to pop up.

Well I like Smoke and I like Zamils Rose, but which one is better? There's only one way to find out

lol

smoke won the fight zamiels rose is rolling on the floor screaming

Rob wrote:I really don't feel that any one, single effect always necessarily has to be 'better' (or 'worse') than any other.

These "XYZ Vs. ABC - Which Is Better?" topics are frequently a little pointless - as anyone will sooner or later mention, it's ALWAYS a matter of personal opinion, handling, presentation, skill etc., which will make or break a performance of any effect.

Yep! It ain't what you do it's the way that you do it!

Stephen Ward wrote:Yep! It ain't what you do it's the way that you do it!

"That's what gets results"

Ah Bananarama, such deep insights into the human condition....

I was waiting for someone to do that!

They couldn't have done it without Fun Boy Three in the background.....

both so good! zamiels rose has the excellent emotional hook but smoke is so perfectly impossible. Shame i can't do either, zamiels rose because i STILL cant do the sodding sleight to produce the cards, and smoke cos of the smoking ban and the expensive d**k. I think zamiels rose has a real elegance and beauty that is not there in smoke. But then smoke almost seems like real magic because it is so clean. so yeh, i dunno love them both!

couldnt have said it better the deck is about £50 i think

allthough i prefer smoke

and apparently the backs are lame, hmph.

what do you mean by lame