Hi Zach - thanks for sharing that with us. First up I don't think you should be too disappointed with yourself. Ut sounds like everyone had fun either though you know you could have done better.
It brings to mind a lecture I saw a few years back at the 2003 Ipswich Magical Society Convention. It was a lecture by a guy called Andy Martin, although he goes by the stage name of Andy Clockwise. Effectively it was the do's and don'ts of performing to kids, and as that wasn't something I ever planned to do at the time I almost didn't even attend the lecture.
Well i am so glad I did. The lecture was superb, Andy is an amazingly talented performer an entertainer, but he started off the lecture with a video of his very first kids party. It was a great story he told that went with it, to cut it down, he was at the time not much more than an amateur hobbyiest who used to perform close-up in the pub for mates, when the sister of a friend asked him to do her child's birthday party as a favour because the magician they had booked cancelled at the last minute.
He thought why not, and winged his way to the nearest magic shop to buy a few props. He ended up spending £150 on magic props, and as they all appeared to be very self working didnt spend much time practicing with them.
I'm not going to go in to the whole story but the video was hilarious You thought your gig went bad!, this was the epitomy of all the don'ts of performing kids magic.
The lecture ended with a clip from one of Andy's last shows - which frankly was so good it could have been a TV show.
I think the bottom line is that it will get better. much better. If you can get a hold of Andy's lecture (and the video) - it will help a great deal. His website is
here but lookin at it it would imply he doesn't do kids anymore. You could email him though and ask if he has any of the lecture notes available.
thanks again though for sharing your experience...
(I can't believe you too the sucker out of the die box!!!)