Tenko wrote:Rob,
Why is the Nudist Deck impracticable for daily use ?
I've used mine several times a night, several nights a week for over 15yrs.
My 100% ideal trick to perform for friends and in casual situations fulfills three quintessential conditions: availability, examinability, and functionality.
I'd like to see someone go over a friend's house or find a pack laying on a bar somewhere that just happens to be a Nudist deck (or Sven deck or anything else). If someone just says, "can you show me something," my first instinct isn't going to pull out a gimmicked pack; it's going to be to either pull out my own pack and let them examine it or borrow one from them.
Further, gimmicked packs aren't examinable. To use a gimmicked deck like the Nudist deck, though, you have to a.) use it for the entire performance, b.) switch decks, or c.) only do one trick.
That brings us to functionality. You can't do many effects with a gimmicked back as compared to a regular pack. The Sven deck is pretty practical in this aspect as you can do a several minute long presentation, but the deck can't be handled between phases or after the trick without a cumbersome deck switch, which takes away from its virtue of examinability.
If you're working professionally, it's certainly practical to use gimmicked decks several times a night, several nights a week; you have a different audience every five or ten minutes working tables or a new audience every hour or two if you're working on the street. I'd consider professional work a special occasion though, as it's outside the realms of what an average hobbyist would consider a performance venue. I don't have numbers, but I'm sure that the ratio of professionals to hobbyists is pretty low.
Accordingly, ungimmicked packs are superior when considering availability, examinability, and functionality. Gimmicked decks do indeed allow for some hard-hitting effects, but they lack in these three principle and quintessential aspects of an ideal trick.
Ciao,
Rob
BTW... My original post
clearly explained that my opinion was just that--my opinion. I'm glad you all value my it so heavily as fact to get so bent out of shape about it
