Hey folks. Went to see this tonight, it promised well - Depp, Bonham Carter, Tim Burton behind the wheel etc.
I have to say - save your money

It was too long (or if it wasn't, it felt like it) and very slow in many parts - every time something vaguely thrilling looked set to happen, it cut back to the boring romantic sub-plot. (1 1/2 hours into the film and we'd seen one brief murder!)
Even though most of it is sung, there are about 4 songs in the whole thing, all pretty dreary and unremarkable, 3 of them are pining love songs and none of them are catchy or emotive. There is no suspense, and what could have been the one saving grace - some really grisly gore - was absent, and in it's place was "stylistic" thin red paint to be all clever and contrast with the almost-black-and-white way it's shot. No jumps, no spine tingling, not even a brooding sense of dread. Worst of all, you come out feeling nothing for the characters.
I haven't seen it but I can say with some certainty you'd be better spending your money going to see "No Country for Old Men."