my choice would be (out of the ones you mentioned and im familiar with):
i would start with red hot mama, not sure on what the second would be from that list - born to perform must have something suitable on it (dont have it myself), and finish on OOTW...make it all cards though...
if you can, work out some patter that will link each trick together though...it will add a nice seamlessness to it all...good luck...
EDIT - for a very simple second phase, why not a cut-deeper force, and a prediction of that force...that way it can lead into a "picking up on what the cards where without looking" kinda conversation...
and if you havent got Royal Road to Card Magic book by the way, get that....
EDIT AGAIN - ooh forgot to say, depending on what sort of character you want to establish when doing magic would dictate what sort of patter used...your reasoning as to why you are doing what you are doing...i'll shut up now...
