Well, you've certainly got some differing opinions here! Told you it'd be easier to buy a book
mark lewis wrote:I do NOT recommend learning it off by heart. You will certainly sound stilted and ten to one you will forget the words halfway through the trick. It's a far better plan to get a general idea of what you wish to say, rehearse it aloud a few times with the props in hand, going through the motions of the trick as you do so, and finally when you come to perform you will sound more spontaneous than if you had learned the patter word for word.
...If someone interrupts you will not be put off whereas if the patter was learnt off by heart a break in the performance could throw you off completely.
This is something you have to weigh up for yourself, but let it be known I and many others disagree with Mark on this point, although he's certainly welcome to his opinions as he's well aware!
Mark - you may be a seasoned pro who is used to stepping out in front of crowds and being spontaneous. But for us mere mortals, 9 out of 10 times, this is what happens: you practice in a mirror, you say to yourself
"then I'd say something here, maybe ask them to do this/that/the other, then I'd patter a bit about XYZ..." but then you get out there and before you know it a routine that was perfect in your room suddenly doesn't seem so robust. When the deck is stickier than you remember, the room sweatier, the people less forgiving, the last thing you want to have to concentrate on is making it all up on the spot and "being spontaneous". Without a clear framework you will rush it, fill it with jibber jabber, forget to treat the magical moments with due gravity and generally fluff things all over the place. You might still complete the routine "successfully" and get a response, but it won't be the response you would have got if the routine had worked smoothly and efficiently.
I am not going to quite the extent that Burger does where he insists his students submit a written script for every routine (although I don't think it hurts). But it is one of these cases where freedom and spontanuity is actually created by planning, scripting and practice - like how if you go on an adventurous holiday, getting visas/money/credit cards/permits etc. for different countries in advance will mean you actually have the freedom to do all sorts of fun things, whilst your "I'll wing it, I'll be spontaneous" friends are stuck in some bereaucratic office for most of the week because they need to apply for a permit before they can cross a border.
I challenge Mark's comment completely with regard to coming across stilted, and that being interrupted will throw you off. I think it's exactly the opposite - these things will happen if you
don't plan out the routine properly, because you'll be nervous, and you'll be trying to think of what to say next, and when someone introduces a tangent you'll then have no point of reference to which you know you must return.
I am absolutely not arguing against using random opportunities, being spontaneous etc - but I think you are in a far better position to do those things effectively and to enjoy yourself whilst you do it if you are safe in the knowledge that you have a very good idea of how the routine is going to pan out.
As you perform more, you will have more confidence to leave the tram tracks of the routine as you've practiced it and go off on the beaten track, just like trainer wheels on a bike. Your script will turn more into a series of bullet points; key instructions, gags and moments that are vital to the routine and upon which more impromptu stuff can be hung.
mark lewis wrote:For example, if you should make an amusing remark extemporaneously, try and remember it for future occasions. You will find as time goes by you will accumulate a stock of these remarks and you can weave them into your performances.
After many performances you will find that you tend to say the same words over and over again anyway, but with more flexibility.
Tomato tomato...

Let's look critically at what's being said here... That after many performances you will settle into a comfortable and practiced presentation. Quite why Mark thinks that setting this out and practicing it before your first presentation is so damaging I don't know. Of course, if funny moments or ideal lines come up regularly, absorb them into your routine - it's not set in stone, and you should trim it, add to it etc. as you see fit. But whatever you do, you will feel more confident with a solid backbone to every routine because then you know that even if every other thing is against you, if you have stumbled across a joyless crowd who provide no banter of their own, you are at least going to get from A to B safely and professionally.
All the best
