Mental Yarn by Bill Goldman

Bought a trick? Let us know what you think!
About to buy a trick? Be sure to read our Archived user reviews here and in the three new sections above before buying!

Moderators: nickj, Lady of Mystery, Mandrake, bananafish, support

Mental Yarn by Bill Goldman

Postby GoldFish » Mar 24th, '04, 12:39



Effect:

The magician asks a spectator to think of an object from a printed list. The selection process is extremely fair. Yet, even before the spectator makes her selection, the magician knows what object she is destined to pick! This is thought reading the way it was meant to be.

The above is the basic effect of Mental Yarn. Direct, stunning mind reading. However, there are many different ways to present the effect. For example, two spectators can assist the magician, each one selecting a different object. Of course, the magician reads both of their thoughts.

Review:

Again, this effect is exactly how it sounds and yet it is an extremely powerful effect. It utilizes very bold psychological principles to achieve an outstanding effect.

What do you get for your money? You get the lists and the principle. If your into ungaffed effects then this is the trick for you. There is no hidden gimmick that forces a particular word on a spectator or anything else like that; it is pure psychology.

Defiantly worth every penny; highest approval.

Rating: 9/10 (less one due to a presentational fault, but this can be rectified by any adept performer.)

Price: £8.99 from www.magicbox.uk.com or www.penguinmagic.com (what isn’t!!?)

All the best,

Will Wood
User avatar
GoldFish
Advanced Member
 
Posts: 1006
Joined: Mar 15th, '04, 16:10
Location: Malawi 25:AH

Postby nickj » Mar 26th, '04, 12:38

Paule Zennon did an adaptation of it in his halloween special a couple of years ago.

Cogito, ergo sum.
Cogito sumere potum alterum.
User avatar
nickj
Elite Member
 
Posts: 2870
Joined: Apr 20th, '03, 21:00
Location: Orpington (29:AH)

Postby GoldFish » Mar 29th, '04, 10:53

It's pretty versatile. You can use props if you want or you can simply use what is given. A full routine is given in the instructions aswell as several routine "ideas"!

All the best,

Will Wood
User avatar
GoldFish
Advanced Member
 
Posts: 1006
Joined: Mar 15th, '04, 16:10
Location: Malawi 25:AH

Mental Yarn

Postby doug segal » Jul 26th, '04, 17:32

The concept is nothing new (synonyms) and some of the items on the list wont work with a UK audience (who over this side of the pond buys a "popsicle"?) but if you throw away the effect and the cards and thoink about the principle you could have a decent mental miracle.

Doug

User avatar
doug segal
Junior Member
 
Posts: 35
Joined: Jul 23rd, '04, 12:35
Location: UK (39:CP)

Postby Sunny » Aug 25th, '04, 02:58

I was actually rather unimpressed with Mental Yarn, since i primarily purchased it to use as an "over the phone effect", which is what the official promo blurb claims that it can be effectively used for. (as well as over the internet). I'm afraid that this is just not true for the simple reason that unlike the situation where an audience member merely has the chance to have a quick glance at the list of selection options, someone on the end of a phone (or keyboard) will have the complete list in front of them during and after completion of the effect. Now it would seem to me that anyone of average intelligence will likely then suss the method with little thought, irrespective of how convincing an effort was made the presentation.

I think that the official description of what this "packet mentalism" effect is capable of is therefore misleading and i hope that this additional review might save someone a few quid had they been primarily looking for an "over the phone mentalism effect", which incidentally seem to be few an far between.

Anyone know of any, other than Banacheck's number reversal / subtraction effect???

User avatar
Sunny
Junior Member
 
Posts: 11
Joined: Aug 10th, '04, 00:21

Postby bananafish » Aug 25th, '04, 09:38

Anyone know of any, other than Banacheck's number reversal / subtraction effect???


As Banachek is mentioned, then the first phase of "Lorrayne's buck" (as seen on the PSI DVD's) would work very nicely over the phone. I seem to think it may actually be called "Lorrayne's Switch", but I can't remember from where.

Marc Paul also has a nice over the phone routine whereby he can divin the zodiac sign of the person on the other end.

User avatar
bananafish
Veteran Member
 
Posts: 5821
Joined: Apr 22nd, '03, 09:43
Location: Simon Shaw. Suffolk, UK (50:SH)

Postby GoldFish » Aug 25th, '04, 13:34

Marc Paul also has a nice over the phone routine whereby he can divin the zodiac sign of the person on the other end.


Damn; Beaten to it again :D . I'd second Marc Paul's effect. It's called "So you can read minds...prove it!" and can be found in his "Direct Mind Reading and Mind Control Effects" pamphlet.

All the best,

Will Wood
User avatar
GoldFish
Advanced Member
 
Posts: 1006
Joined: Mar 15th, '04, 16:10
Location: Malawi 25:AH

Postby Sunny » Aug 26th, '04, 00:18

Thanks for the response Re: phone effects. Must say however, that i always found Marc Paul's zodiac sign divination rather contrived. I mean if we are meant to be reading minds, should it really need that many questions to figure it out? Comes across as a bit of a fishing trip to me. But then i always was a bit on the picky side.

Now where did i leave my copy of MENTAL YAWN :-) ???

Oh, now i remember, the trash got collected yesterday!

User avatar
Sunny
Junior Member
 
Posts: 11
Joined: Aug 10th, '04, 00:21

Postby Wmental » Aug 30th, '04, 01:08

GoldFish wrote:
Marc Paul also has a nice over the phone routine whereby he can divin the zodiac sign of the person on the other end.


Damn; Beaten to it again :D . I'd second Marc Paul's effect. It's called "So you can read minds...prove it!" and can be found in his "Direct Mind Reading and Mind Control Effects" pamphlet.


Hi friend!

Really this effect is very more stronger if we inside "cold reading" in it.
In phone this magic takes 10 in 10 (score)!

Wmental
Junior Member
 
Posts: 25
Joined: Jun 2nd, '04, 04:34
Location: Brazil (32:sh/wp)


Return to Archived Reviews - now closed

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests