I'm not taking offence at your comments and you haven't seen me perform. I don't think that that the tricks I perform are bland, and judging by the general posts it would appear that I perform many of the same or similar tricks that others perform, with perhaps one or two exceptions. I get extremely good feedback from my audiences, as well as repeat bookings and referrals so I don't think I'm a bland performer - in fact I know that I'm not! You can't judge a persons ability to perform and entertain through a few sentences of text.
Sorry, it wasn't meant to be a personal dig at you as a performer. I haven't seen you perform so I have no right to judge you in that way, and I would hope that I never would.
Bringing it back to the subject, the point I was trying to make was that you can't simply throw three effects together from a rotational system and expect them to be entertaining. It's a matter of routining and actually fusing the effects into one climactic routine. In actual fact I think we are both arguing the same point from different angles.
Some people work as hard on the presentation as on the moves themselves - and that doesn't mean their moves are simple!
Good point and in my opinion I believe that every magician who takes performance seriously should be putting
at least the same amount of effort into their presentation as they put into their "moves".
You can use the third as backup (e.g. have to perform for the whole room, have to entertain a business table...)
Kati raises an interesting point in that you should always have something else to perform. An encore if you want to call it that. You will always come across situations in which you have finished your routine but the audience a) have time to see more and b) want to see more (not neccessarily in that order). In these situations you should always have a killer stand alone effect which will really reel them in.
When I say that this effect should be stand alone, what I mean is that it is not just the filler or closer from another routine. Instead it is a whole routine in itself. A good example of this would be an ambitious card routine or a chop cup routine. Both of these, and many other effects out there, contain all of the elements of a good routine ie a begining, a middle and an end.