by seige » Apr 29th, '03, 09:42
Dale
The point I'm trying to make here is that you stated that this 'skin piercing in a channel' handling was the method employed by Blaine, and I was merely disputing that.
I agree, as previously mentioned that Fakirs and the like would perform all sorts of crazy insertions and penetrations in the name of gross-out art, but I fail to see that Blaine would take such a risk (as you state, it's DUMB).
Eastern magic takes a mystical and spiritual form, and the belief that the body can be controlled to ignore pain is strong, even to the extent of being part of religious festivals in some countries to this date, which involve piercing rituals and life-threatening insertions (how does a pushbike through the side walls of the mouth sound??? it's true!)
And as for the reference to belly button piercings... an ex-girlfriend of mine underwent this procedure before it became a 'national pastime', and the pain, infection and two weeks of bruising were not what I'd call a painless experience (and neither would she!).
My authoritive American source, who is a walking encyclopedia of magic, claims that the effect performed by Blaine on the TV show would have required a 'channel' of about four inches laterally parallell to the surface of the skin in order to be performed. And logically, due to the transparency of the skin in that area, BLACK thread would need to lie under about 1/6 - 1/8" below the skin for most of the whole 4 inches. Not pleasant!
Orchante indeed also performed the effect, along with sword swallowing and fire-breathing etc, and I would not dispute that someone like him could use this method (especially as I remember, he wore a cummerbund, which could facilitate a shorter sub-skin channel).
There's no denying that there have been REAL odd piercings in the past, but if you've ever seen this effect performed with latex (or indeed the excellent Anderson version of 'needle through arm' - including blood from the wound), the prosthetic effects are practically indistinguishable from real, and a lot less painful (except trying to get latex of hair!) - and because magicians are all about ILLUSION, the latex route seems obvious.
It only increases the 'mystical' image that Blaine portrays to hear tales like 'yes, the string really IS in his stomach', and I imagine that is what he wants, as it seems his goal to appear as a 'powerful magician' to the world... BUT... would a man who performed a quite obvious and 'camera enhanced' version of a Balducci levitation go to that trouble for his art??? His public love him, and believe in him. And we respect him for that.
I think that this is my own opinion, and I'll not force further judgement, that Blaine used makeup. And I would imagine that most modern magicians would go the same route.
The day that magicians cross the border between reality and illusion will be the day that the Knife through Arm illusion is done with a real, standard kitchen knife, and not an £85 prop (would you pay £85 for a blunt knife???).