by Demitri » Feb 21st, '06, 23:37
I agree with kati's points.
The handling of the effect seems awkward. I don't want to sound like I'm jumping on you, but certain elements need to be kept in mind when working on an effect.
When asking a spectator to sign a card, holding it in the way you did here is very suspicious. Why can't you put the card down or hand it to the spectator to sign?
The way you place the card on the table seems fishy, too. Also, this handling requires you to watch your angles, and spectators to either side can spot what is going on.
I'm assuming you are trying to sell the concept of a single card here - and the isolation from the deck helps to promote that, but everything else makes the effect seem peculiar. I'd take Kati's points to heart, and maybe think about different ways to handle the card and make the effect more powerful.