by Farlsborough » Dec 19th, '07, 19:24
I generally hate Christmas pop songs, even "the classics" - they just sound tacky from the off and make me think of horrible cheap tinsel littering the streets, toys manufactured specially for Christmas that will have broken by new year and almost anything for sale in Clinton's cards.
However! I do really enjoy covers of carols by indie bands. Sufjan Stevens' version of O Holy Night, Lauren Laverne's In the Bleak Midwinter, Bright Eyes' God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen, brilliant.
Some decent bands have actually written decent Christmas songs, for instance Eels "Everything's Gonna Be Cool This Christmas"... Yo La Tengo, Low, Calexico - all of them have songs that blow the usual bilge out of the water.
P.S. A "you must choose" scenario for you... eternal condemnation for Cliff or for Elton?! I mean, Cliff would lose out on a purely musical basis, but Elton's such a schleaze...